The Political Mobilization of the New Religious Right by Bryan Le Beau
Part III



Whither the New Christian Right

     The previously noted caveats notwithstanding, the New Christian Right's ability to restructure itself after the 1992 election and its organization ever since are impressive.

"Rather than rejecting the values of the wider society, the Christian Coalition sought to reengage the outside world."

In predicting its future, however, we must take into account the growing influence of evangelicals in what was once a fundamentalist led movement. This is of major consequence, first, because evangelicals comprise the fastest growing religious group in America (Solomon 1996, 411), and second, as noted earlier, because evangelicals are wealthier, better educated, more sub/urban, and less conservative than fundamentalists (Solomon 1996, 415). Contemporary evangelicalism is a world-affirming faith, capable of adapting to its surrounding culture, and the effect of this world-affirming view appears to have brought about, or at least accommodated, the reinvention of the New Christian Right.
Photo of Ralph Reed     The Reverend Jerry Falwell, co-founder of Moral Majority is a fundamentalist, as were most of the NCR's early leaders (Shibley 1998, 70). In 1986, however, when Falwell disassembled Moral Majority, which was becoming ineffective, Pat Robertson became the focal point of the movement. Robertson is a socially conservative evangelical, but he opened the door to more moderate evangelicals when, in 1989, he founded the Christian Coalition and anointed Ralph Reed executive director. Born in 1961, Reed was part of a new generation of born-again Christians who were not reared in a fundamentalist subculture or even a conservation evangelical culture. Reed was a contemporary evangelical with an essentially political vocation (ibid. 81).
     Reed's work with the Christian Coalition between 1989 and 1997 in effect transformed the Christian Right into a modern political organization, both tactically and ideologically. The Christian Coalition affirmed the basic tenets of conservative Protestant belief but rejected the extreme anti-intellectual and sectarian tendencies of fundamentalism. Rather than rejecting the values of the wider society, the Christian Coalition sought to reengage the outside world. It took for granted many of the cultural norms of middle class life as it was being redefined by the baby-boom generation (Roof 1993).
     Following the Republican Party's impressive gains in 1994, Reed endorsed the Contract with America and unveiled the Contract with the American Family--conservative and "pro-family" but not belligerent (Martin 1997, 364). Reed spelled out the Christian Coalition's new position in his book Active Faith, published in 1996. He cautioned religious conservatives to "resist the temptation to replace the social engineering of the left with the social engineering of the right by forcing compliance with the moral principles that motivate us so deeply." Religious conservatives, he said, must shun harsh language on critical issues--abortion and homosexuality--and learn to speak of their opponents with charity (Reed 1996, 28).
     Reed angered some to his right by endorsing presidential candidate Bob Dole in 1996 when Dole appeared likely to select a pro-choice running mate (Diamond 1996, 44), but Reed's decision was consistent with his ultimate goal of building a political organization that would be a player in mainstream politics (Solomon 1996, 414). As Mark Shibley put it: "Reed clearly has a vision of the role of religious conservatives in politics that is broader than the sectarian movement he inherited (Shibley 1998, 82).
     The future of the Christian Coalition, and of the now-not-so-new Christian Right depends on finding new, equally effective leadership to replace Ralph Reed. Any pronouncements on Randy Tate would be premature. Tate did succeed in holding on to religious conservatives alienated by Reed's more moderate, pragmatic policies, but he also presided over the electoral reversals of 1998 and faces dissent in the ranks for the year 2000.
     By its very nature, the future of the Christian Coalition will continue to be dependent on galvanizing issues. But perhaps the greatest danger to the Christian Right as a social and political movement may grow out of its very success. The truly "New" Christian Right, led by evangelicals, has been successful because it has learned to engage the world. It has learned to engage the world because it has become more like the world. But if it becomes too much like the world, it will cease to be an effective voice for the "outsiders" whom the Christian Right has represented for most of this century (Beinart 1998, 29). If that happens, as did the "old" Christian Right in the 1920s, the movement will fall into disarray, and its more conservative constituents will retreat, once again, to saving souls, not the nation.

REFERENCES


Allinsmith, Wesley, and Beverly Allinsmith. 1948. "Religious Affiliation and Politico-Economic Attitudes: A Study of Eight Major U.S. Religious Groups." Public Opinion Quarterly 12:377-389.

Baker, Ross K., Laurily K. Epstein, and Rodney D. Furth. 1981. "Matters of Life and Death: Social, Political, and Religious Correlates of Attitudes on Abortion." American Politics Quarterly 9:89-102.

Baker, Tod A., Robert P. Steed, and Laurence W. Moreland, eds. 1983. Religion and Politics in the South: Mass and Elite Perspectives. New York: Praeger.

Barone, Michael. 1996. "Faith in Numbers." National Review 48:56-58.

Barrett, Sharon W., and Richard J. Harris. 1982. "Recent Changes in Predictors of Abortion Attitudes." Sociology and Social Research 66:320-334.

Beatty, Kathleen Murphy, and Oliver Walter. 1989. "A Group Theory of Religion and Politics: The Clergy As Group Leaders." Western Political Quarterly 42:129-146.

Beinart, Peter, 1998. "Battle for the 'Burbs." The New Republic, October 19, 25-29.

Billington, Monroe, and Cal Clark. 1991. "Baptist Preachers and the New Deal." Journal of Church and State 33:255-270.

Bruce, Steve. 1988. The Rise and Fall of the New Christian Right. New York: Oxford University Press.

_____. 1994. "The Inevitable Failure of the New Christian Right." Sociology of Religion54: 229-242.

Brudney, Jeffrey L., and Gary W. Copeland. 1984. "Evangelicals As a Political Force: Reagan and the 1980 Religious Vote." Social Science Quarterly 65:1072-1079.

Buell, Emmett H., and Lee Sigelman. 1985. "An Army That Meets Every Sunday? Popular Support for the Moral Majority in 1980." Social Science Quarterly 66:426- 434.

Burner, David. 1967. The Politics of Provincialism: The Democratic Party in Transition, 1918-1932. New York: W.W. Norton.

Burnham, Walter Dean. 1968. "American Voting Behavior and the 1964 Election." Midwest Journal of Political Science 12:1-40.

Buzzard, Lynn. 1989. "The ‘Coming Out' of Evangelicals." In Contemporary Evangelical Political Involvement: An Analysis and Assessment, ed. Corwin E. Smidt, 133-146. Lanham, Md.: University Press of America.

Carwardine, Richard. 1993. Evangelicals and Politics in Antebellum America. New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press.

Christian Coalition. 1995. Contract With the American Family. Nashville, Tenn.: Moorings.

"Christian Coalition Sees 1998 as Crucial." 1998. Omaha World Herald (Virginia Pilot), June 14, 23A.

"Christian Coalition Speakers Take Two Different Stances." 1998. Omaha World Herald. (New York Times), September 19, 6A.

Clabaugh, Gary K. 1974. Thunder on the Right: The Protestant Fundamentalists. Chicago: Nelson-Hall.

Conover, Pamela Johnson. 1983. "The Mobilization of the New Right: A Test of Various Explanations." Western Political Quarterly 36:632-649.

Converse, Philip E. 1966. "Religion and Politics: The 1960 Election." In Elections and the Political Order, ed. Angus Campbell, Philip E. Converse, Warren E. Miller, and Donald Stokes, 96-124. New York: John Wiley.

Craig, Wyn. 1987. The Fiery Cross: The KKK in America. New York: Simon and Schuster.

Crawford, Alan. 1980. Thunder on the Right. New York: Pantheon.

D'Antonio, Michael. 1989. Fall From Grace: The Failed Crusade of the Christian Right. New York: Farrar, Straus, and Giroux.

Dawidowicz, Lucy S., and Leon J. Goldstein, eds. 1974. Politics in a Pluralist Democracy: Studies of Voting in the 1960 Election. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood.

Diamond, Sara. 1996. "Forward, March: Bob Dole and the Christian Right." Z Magazine, November, 44-47.

Dixon, Richard D., Diane E. Levy, and Roger C. Lowery. 1988. "Asking the ‘Born- Again' Question." Review of Religious Research 30:33-39.

Edsall, Thomas B. 1994. "Revolt of the Discontented." Washington Post Weekly Edition, 21 November, 28.

Fitzgerald, Frances. 1981. "A Disciplined, Charging Army." New Yorker, 18 May, 53-141.

Fowler, Robert Booth. 1982. A New Engagement: Evangelical Political Thought, 1966- 1976. Grand Rapids, Mich.: Eerdman's.

Gallup, George, Jr. 1981. "Divining the Devout: The Polls and Religious Belief." Public Opinion 4:20, 41.

Glazer, Nathan. 1986. "The ‘Social Agenda'." In Perspectives on the Reagan Years, ed. John L. Palmer, 5-30. Washington, D.C.: Urban Institute.

Goldstein, David. 1998. "Turnout a Key for Democrats." The Kansas City Star, November 5, A1, A15.

Green, John C., and James L. Guth. 1988. "The Christian Right in the Republican Party: The Case of Pat Robertson's Supporters." Journal of Politics 50:150-168.

Green, John C., James L. Guth, and Kevin Hill. 1993. "Faith and Election: The Christian Right in Congressional Campaigns, 1978-1988." Journal of Politics 55:80-91.

Green, John C., James L. Guth, Lyman A. Kellstedt, and Corwin E. Smidt. 1994. "The Characteristics of Christian Political Activists: An Interest Group Analysis." In Christian Political Activism at the Crossroads, ed. William R. Stevenson, 133-172. Lanham, Md.: University Press of America.

Grupp, Frederick W., and William M. Newman. 1973. "Political Ideology and Religious Preference: The John Birch Society and the Americans for Democratic Action." Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 12:401-413.

Guth, James L., John C. Green, Corwin E. Smidt, and Margaret M. Poloma. 1991. "Pulpits and Politics: The Protestant Clergy in the 1988 Presidential Election." In The Bible and the Ballot Box, ed. James L. Guth and John C. Green, 73-93. Boulder: Westview.

Hertel, Bradley R., and Michael Hughes. 1987. "Religious Affiliation, Attendance, and Support for ‘Pro-Family' Issues in the United States." Social Forces 65:858-882.

Hertzke, Allen D. 1995. "Religion and the Republican Congress." Extensions 7-10.

Jelen, Ted G. 1987. "The Effects of Religious Separatism on White Protestants in the 1984 Presidential Election." Sociological Analysis 48:30-45.

_____. 1993. "The Political Consequences of Religious Group Attitudes." Journal of Politics 55:178-190.

Jelen, Ted G., Corwin E. Smidt, and Clyde Wilcox. 1993. "The Political Effects of the Born-Again Phenomenon." In Rediscovering the Religious Factor in American Politics, ed. David C. Leege and Lyman A. Kellstedt, 199-215. Armonk, N.Y.: M.E. Sharpe.

Jelen, Ted G., and Clyde Wilcox. 1993. "Preaching to the Converted: The Causes and Consequences of Viewing Religious Television." In Rediscovering the Religious Factor in American Politics, ed. David C. Leege and Lyman A. Kellstedt, 255-269. Armonk, N.Y.: M. E. Sharpe.

Kellstedt, Lyman A. 1989a. "Evangelicals and Political Realignment." In Contemporary Evangelical Political Involvement: An Analysis and Assessment, ed. Corwin E. Smidt, 99-118. Lanham, Md.: University Press of America.

_____. 1989b. "The Falwell Issue Agenda: Sources of Support Among White Protestant Evangelicals." In Research in the Social Scientific Study of Religion, ed. Monte L. Lynn and David O. Moberg, 109-132. Greenwich, Conn.: JAI.

Kellstedt, Lyman A., John C. Green, James L. Guth, and Corwin E. Smidt. 1994. "Religious Voting Blocs in the 1992 Election: The Year of the Evangelical?" Sociology of Religion 55:307-326.

Kellstedt, Lyman A., and Corwin Smidt. 1991. "Measuring Fundamentalism: An Analysis of Different Operational Strategies." Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion30:259-278.

_____. 1993. "Doctrinal Beliefs and Political Behavior: Views of the Bible." In Rediscovering the Religious Factor in American Politics, ed. David C. Leege and Lyman A. Kellstedt, 177-198. Armonk, N.Y.: M. E. Sharpe.

Kleppner, Paul. 1979. The Third Electoral System. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.

Levine, Lawrence W. 1975. Defender of the Faith: William Jennings Bryan, The Last Decade, 1915-1925. New York: Oxford University Press.

Lienesch, Michael. 1993. Redeeming America: Piety and Politics in the New Christian Right. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.

Lipset, Seymour Martin, and Earl Raab. 1981. "The Election and the Evangelicals." Commentary 71:25-31.

Lorentzen, Louis J. 1980. "Evangelical Life-Style Concerns Expressed in Political Action." Sociological Analysis 41:144-154.

Martin, William. 1997. With God on Our Side: The Rise of the Religious Right in America. New York: Broadway Books.

McClosky, Herbert, and John Zaller. 1984. The American Ethos. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Miller, Warren E., Arthur H. Miller, and Edward J. Schneider. 1980. American National Election Studies Data Sourcebook, 1952-1978. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Moen, Matthew C. 1984. "School Prayer and the Politics of Life-Style Concern." Social Science Quarterly 65:1065-1071. _____. 1994.

"From Revolution to Evolution: The Changing Nature of the Christian Right." In Religion: North American Style, eds. Thomas Dowdy and Patrick McNamara. New Brunswick, N.J.: Rutgers University Press, 1997.

Nemeth, Roger J., and Donald A. Luidens. 1989. "The New Christian Right and Mainline Protestantism: The Case of the Reformed Church in America." Sociological Analysis49:343-352.

Novick, Michael. 1996. "The 1996 Elections in the United States." http://www.comlink.apc.org/fic/newslett/eng/29/page_12.htm

Orum, Anthony M. 1970. "Religion and the Rise of the Radical White: The Case of Southern Wallace Support in 1968." Social Science Quarterly 51: 674-688.

Page, Ann, and Donald Clelland. 1978. "The Kanawha County Textbook Controversy: A Study in Alienation and Lifestyle Concern." Social Forces 57:265-281.

Patel, Kant, Denny Pilant, and Gary L. Rose. 1982. "Born-Again Christians in the Bible Belt." American Politics Quarterly 10:255-272.

Phillips, Kevin P. 1982. Post-Conservative America. New York: Vintage.

Pierard, Richard V. 1983. "From Evangelical Exclusiveness to Ecumenical Openness: Billy Graham and Socio-Political Issues." Journal of Ecumenical Studies 20:425-446.

Public Opinion. 1985. "Southern Whites: The Great Conversion." Public Opinion 7:34.

Pyle, Ralph E. 1993. "Faith and Commitment to the Poor: Theological Orientation and Support for Government Assistance Measures." Sociology of Religion 54:385-401.

Reed, Ralph. 1996. Active Faith: How Christians Are Changing the Soul of American Politics. New York: Free Press.

Reno, Robert. 1998. "Religion and Politics Didn't Mix." Omaha World Herald (Newsday), November 13, 15A.

Ribuffo, Leo. 1983. The Old Christian Right. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.

Roof, Wade Clark. 1993. A Generation of Seekers: The Spiritual Journeys of the Baby Boom Generation. San Francisco: Harper Collins.

Roof, Wade Clark, and William McKinney. 1987. American Mainline Religion: Its Changing Shape and Future. New Brunswick, N.J.: Rutgers University Press.

Rothenberg, Stuart, and Frank Newport. 1984. The Evangelical Voter. Washington, D.C.: Free Congress Research and Education Foundation.

Rozell, Mark J., and Clyde Wilcox, eds. 1995. Got at the Grass Roots: The Christian Right in the 1994 Elections., Lanham, Md.: Rowman and Littlefield.

Schneider, William. 1989. "Trouble for the GOP." Public Opinion 12:2, 59-60.

_____. 1995. "Stealth Strategy for the Religious Right?' National Journal, 27 May, 1314.

Shibley, Mark A. 1998. "Contemporary Evangelicals: Born-Again and World Affirming." Annals 558:67-87.

Shupe, Anson, and William Stacy. 1983. "The Moral Majority Constituency." In The New Christian Right, ed. Robert C. Liebman and Robert Wuthnow, 104-117. New York: Aldine.

Sigelman, Lee, and Stanley Presser. 1988. "Measuring Public Support for the New Christian Right: The Perils of Point Estimation." Public Opinion Quarterly 52:325- 337.

Sigelman, Lee, Clyde Wilcox, and Emmett H. Buell Jr. 1987. "An Unchanging Minority: Popular Support for the Moral Majority, 1980 and 1984." Social Science Quarterly68:876-884.

Smidt, Corwin. 1988. "Evangelicals Within Contemporary American Politics: Differentiating Between Fundamentalist and Non-Fundamentalist Evangelicals." Western Political Quarterly 41: 601-620.

_____. 1989a. "Identifying Evangelical Respondents: An Analysis of ‘Born-Again' and Bible Questions Used Across Different Surveys." In Religion and Political Behavior in the United States, ed. Ted G. Jelen, 23-44. New York: Praeger.

_____. 1989b. "‘Praise the Lord' Politics: A Comparative Analysis of the Social Characteristics and Political Views of American Evangelical and Charismatic Christians." Sociological Analysis 50:53-72.

_____. 1993. "Evangelical Voting Patterns: 1976-1988." In No Longer Exiles: The Religious New Right in American Politics, ed. Michael Cromartie, 85-117. Washington, D.C.: Ethics and Public Policy Center.

Smidt, Corwin, and Paul Kellstedt. 1992. "Evangelicals in the Post-Reagan Era: An Analysis of Evangelical Voters in the 1988 Presidential Election." Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 31:330-338.

Solomon, Burt. 1996. "Christian Soldiers." National Journal, February 24, 410-415.

Stockton, Ron R. 1989. "The Evangelical Phenomenon: A Falwell-Graham Typology." In Contemporary Evangelical Political Involvement: An Analysis and Assessment, ed. Corwin E. Smidt, 45-74. Lanham, Md.: University Press of America.

Tamney, Joseph, and Stephen D. Johnson. 1983. "The Moral Majority in Middletown." Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 22:145-157.

Tate, Randy. 1998. "Speech at the National Press Club, September 16, 1998." http://www.cc.org/publications/speeches98/npc0998.html

Wald, Kenneth D. 1991. "Ministering to the Nation: The Campaigns of Jesse Jackson and Pat Robertson." In Nominating the President, ed. Emmett H. Buell Jr. and Lee S. Sigelman, 119-149. Knoxville: University of Tennessee Press.

_____. 1997. Religion and Politics in the United States, 3rd ed. Washington, D.C.: Congressional Quarterly.

Wald, Kenneth D., and Michael B. Lupfer. 1983. "Religion and Political Attitudes in the Urban South." In Religion and Politics in the South: Mass and Elite Perspectives, ed. Tod A. Baker, Robert B. Steed, and Laurence W. Moreland, 84-100. New York: Praeger Special Studies.

Warner, R. Stephen. 1979. "Theoretical Barriers to the Understanding of Evangelical Christianity." Sociological Analysis 40:1-9.

Wattenberg, Ben J. 1995. Values Matter Most. New York: Free Press.

Wilcox, Clyde. 1986. "Fundamentalists and Politics: An Analysis of the Effects of Differing Operational Definitions." Journal of Politics 48:1041-1051.

_____. 1989. "Evangelicals and the Moral Majority." Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 28:400-414.

_____. 1992a. God's Warriors: The Christian Right in Twentieth-Century America. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press.

_____. 1992b. "Race, Religion, Region, and Abortion Attitudes." Sociological Analysis53:97-105.

Wuthnow, Robert. 1983. "The Political Rebirth of American Evangelicals." In The New Christian Right, ed. Robert C. Liebman and Robert Wuthnow, 168-187. New York: Aldine.

Young, John Hardin, Sherry A. Swirsky, and Jay B. Myerson. 1995. "Going to the Grassroots: How the Christian Coalition is Filling the Void." Campaigns and Elections, July, 34.

Zwier, Robert. 1982. "The New Christian Right and the 1980 Elections." In New Christian Politics, eds. David G. Bromley and Anson Shupe. Macon, GA.: Mercer University Press, 1984.


Mobilization of the New Christian Right Part 2

Mobilization of the New Christian Right Part 1


homeReturn to the American Religious Experience Main Page